Screen Printing vs Digital Printing: Key Differences

Choosing between screen printing and digital printing can be tricky, especially if you want the best results for your shirts, hoodies, or custom gifts. 

Both methods have their own strengths, so let’s break down how each works, when to use them, and how to pick what’s right for you.

How Does Screen Printing Work?

Screen printing is a classic method that’s been around for decades. It uses a mesh screen, special ink, and a squeegee. Your design is made into a stencil on the screen, and then ink is pushed through the open parts of the stencil onto your shirt, bag, or even glass.

Setting up for screen printing takes some time, especially if you have lots of colors in your design (each color needs its own screen). But once everything is ready, you can print hundreds or even thousands of items quickly, and each one will look the same.

📌Want to see the whole step-by-step process? Check out this complete guide on how screen printing works.

How Does Digital Printing Work?

Digital printing, sometimes called direct-to-garment (DTG) printing, is much newer. It works a bit like your home inkjet printer—your design is sent straight from a computer to a special printer that sprays the ink onto your fabric or item.

There’s no need for screens or stencils, so setup is fast. You can print one shirt or one hundred, and each can have a different design or even a photo. Digital printing is perfect for small batches, samples, or super-detailed images with lots of colors and shading.

Screen Printing vs Digital Printing: What’s the Big Difference?

Pros and Cons of Screen Printing

📌Want to learn more? Discover everything you need to know about screen printing.

Which Is Better for T-Shirts and Apparel?

If you want matching shirts for a team, club, or event, screen printing is the way to go. The prints are strong, bold, and last a long time. For small batches, samples, or if you want to print a photo or a colorful drawing, digital printing is a smart choice.

Digital prints feel softer on the shirt, while screen prints can feel thicker—especially if the design is big. Both methods work on cotton, but digital printing is best on 100% cotton for the brightest results.

Screen Printing vs Digital Printing for Business and Bulk Orders

For businesses that need hundreds of shirts, bags, or uniforms, screen printing saves money and time. Once the screens are set up, each print is fast and consistent. 

If you want to offer lots of custom designs or print-on-demand products, digital printing gives you the flexibility to print just what you need, when you need it.

Screen Printing vs Digital Printing for Custom and One-Off Designs

If you just need one special shirt for a birthday, a photo pillow for a friend, or a small run of custom gifts, digital printing is perfect. 

There’s no minimum order, and you can print as many colors as you want—no extra cost. Screen printing is best saved for bigger orders, since the setup takes time and money.

How to Choose Between Screen Printing and Digital Printing

Think about what you need before you pick a printing method.  

• Budget: Big orders are cheaper with screen printing; small ones are cheaper with digital.  
• Quantity: Need just a few? Go digital. Need hundreds? Go to screen.  
• Design: Lots of colors or photos? Digital wins. Simple logos or text? Screen is great.  
• Timeline: Digital printing is faster for small runs; screen printing is faster for big ones (after setup).  
• Fabric: Both work on cotton, but screen printing can handle more surfaces.

Still not sure? Make a checklist of what matters most: price, speed, color, fabric, and order size. If you have a tricky project, ask your printer for samples or advice.

Conclusion

Screen printing and digital printing both have their place. If you want bold, long-lasting prints for a big group, screen printing is usually the best choice. If you need detailed images, lots of colors, or just a few items, digital printing is fast, flexible, and easy.

When deciding between screen printing vs digital printing, think about your design, how many you need, and your budget. Both methods can give you awesome results if you pick the right one for your project.

Curious about other printing methods? Check out our guide comparing screen printing vs sublimation for even more options.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is screen printing cheaper than digital printing?

Screen printing typically has higher initial setup costs due to screen creation, making it less economical for very small batches. 

However, for larger volume orders (usually 25 pieces or more), the cost per item becomes significantly cheaper than digital printing as the setup costs are spread out. 

Digital printing has minimal setup fees, making it more cost-effective for small runs, samples, or designs with many colors requiring complex setups in screen printing.

Which printing method is better for detailed designs and photos?

Digital printing (specifically Direct-to-Garment or DTG) generally handles high detail, intricate designs, gradients, and full-color photographs better than screen printing.

 It functions like an inkjet printer, allowing for precise color blending and fine resolution directly onto the fabric.

While screen printing can produce detailed images, it becomes complex and costly with many colors or photographic elements, making digital the preferred choice for such artwork.

When should I use screen printing vs digital printing?

Use screen printing for larger quantity orders, especially those with fewer colors, where vibrancy and long-term durability on various fabrics are important. It's ideal for team uniforms, event merchandise, or bulk apparel orders due to its lower per-item cost at scale. 

Choose digital printing (DTG) for small runs, one-off custom items, designs with high detail or many colors (like photos), and when a quick turnaround is needed on compatible fabrics (like cotton).

Which print lasts longer: screen printing or digital printing?

Traditionally, screen prints are known for being more durable and lasting longer through washes compared to digital prints. 

The thicker ink layer in screen printing often creates a stronger bond with the fabric fibers. While the longevity of digital (DTG) prints has improved significantly with better technology and inks, they can sometimes fade faster than screen prints over many washes if not cared for properly.
 

Related articles:

A Portable Drawing Assistant to Enhance Creative Efficiency 

How to Do Screen Printing on Fabric: 7 Simple Steps